I would abduct him and a dozen other guys, strip them naked, attach wireless choke collars, and imprison them in a mansion.
On the first day they'll wake up groggy, naked, confused, and surrounded by their sexy housemates. They'll explore, and find the mansion equipped with ample food, a pool, huge showers, a gym, playrooms, luxurious bedrooms - all the amenities of a resort. They'll pass the day getting to know each other, playing games, searching for an exit, working out, chatting, and awkwardly trying to hide their erections... some of them of course giving in to temptation.
That night, hidden speakers in the collars will summon them to one of the mansion's living rooms, where they will learn that they are playing "survivor", and being watched by hidden cameras all over the house. Every night the audience will vote one of them out. At that moment, one of the studs - a body builder - notices his collar is slowly tightening. He asphyxiates before them, in his death throes squirting his pleasure over the writhing bodies of the men trying frantically to help him. After several minutes of helplessly watching his fresh corpse twitch and settle, their collars crackle once more to life: "You are here for the amusement of the audience. Try to keep their interest."
What the men are NOT told:
* Every day it is possible to gain immunity from that night's vote... by murdering someone else.
* Some of the men have very dangerous hidden sides.
* As contestants die, new men appear in the mansion to replace them.