Iwould like this guy in a foxhole with me. He looks more like a soldier. Please excuse me for altering your photo, but the boots are a trigger for me. The rest of him doesn't matter. "You can't judge the depth of the well by the handle on the pump"
I like both of them with and without their clothes.
My first choice would be the fellow with the more muscled body.
I suspect he has a very handsome Ass too.