Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I wish that Matt would walking in to check and found out so Gary had to knock him out. Then force Matt to watch Gacy strangle Ben to death and uses Ben's mouth to milk Matt's load before killing himChapter 5. Should have waited
Gacy relaxed at home, he was doing some work from home when he was interrupted by a knock at the door. Heading up to answer it he was surprised to see Ben standing before him.
Ben was the younger brother of Matt who was one of the co-owners of the gym that Gacy owned. And Gacy was a little surprised to see the athletic young man standing at his door.
“Hi Ben, Errr what can I do for you?” Gacy asked.
“Hi John, look I need a massive favour. Matt will kill me if he knew I was here though,” Ben explained
Gacy looked around Ben was an attractive young man with a nice body, one that Gacy had thought about for a while “Does anyone know you came here?” The killer asked as he looked around.
“Nope. Like I said they wouldn’t be happy if they knew I was here.” A jumpy Ben explained
Gacy invited the young man in and asked what he could do for him.
“I’m gonna be honest with you John. I need your help.” Ben said “I’ve been pestering Matt for a job at the gym and the arsehole says I’m not ready for it. I mean look. I’ve been working hard on my body and know I’m more than ready.” With that Ben removed his shirt and now stood shirtless.
“What reason did Matt give you though?” Gacy asked as he got a good look at the shirtless young man.
“He didn’t give me a specific reason. He just said he doesn’t think I’m ready.” Ben explained “I mean look at me. Do you think I’m ready?”
Ben then proceeded to pull off a few poses and show Gacy that he was indeed ready.
“I don’t think I should be getting involved in this.” Gacy said “This is an issue between you and your brother.”
“Please John.” Ben begged “I know you can talk some sense into him. I’d do anything to get you to help.”
Gacy smiled he had an idea. He grabbed the handcuffs from one of the drawers and told Ben to put them on him. Ben was confused and did as Gacy asked. Gacy explained these were prop handcuffs he used for his clown act and told Ben to watch as he removed them from his wrists. He told Ben that if he could remove them from himself then he would tell Matt to give Ben a job.
Thinking this was going to be easy Ben agreed and allowed Gacy to handcuff him.
“Ok I’m gonna time you. You ready?” Gacy asked the handcuffed young man.
“This will be a piece of piss.” Ben exclaimed cockily and began to twist his arms in an effort to free himself from the handcuffs. The young man tried with all his might as he moaned and groaned in attempt to release himself.
After a good few minutes of trying Ben looked at Gacy “This is harder than I thought.” He laughed “What’s the trick.”
Gacy gave Ben a smile and laughed as he said “The trick is you have to have the key.” And dangled the handcuff key in front of the helpless young man.
“Ok very funny. I fell for it.” Ben laughed “Let me go now.”
Gacy reassured Ben he was coming to let him out of the handcuffs but instead of releasing Ben, the killer flung a ligature around his neck and pulled it tight.
“Errgh John what are you doing?” Ben managed to utter as the ligature was pulled tight. Gacy had him where he wanted and the handcuffed young man was helpless as Gacy dragged him back to the sofa in the game room strangled him to death.
Gacy had been strangling Ben for around a minute when he was interrupted by a loud knock at his door. He initially ignored it but the knocking grew louder. Gacy didn’t want anybody snooping around and knew he had no option but to stop his attack on Ben for now.
“Looks like you get a mini reprieve.” Gacy joked as he loosened the ligature that saw Ben let out a cry for help in an attempt to grab the attention of the person at the door.
“Oh no, you don’t,” Gacy said calmly as he grabbed a wash towel from the side and shoved it deep into Ben’s mouth. Gacy left the bound hunk lying on the sofa as he locked the door to the room behind him.
Upon opening the door Gacy was shocked to see his business partner and Ben’s older brother Matt standing at the door. Thoughts ran through his mind - did Matt know Ben was here? Was he checking up on his brother?
He quickly snapped out of all the thoughts and brought himself back to the real world.
“Sorry I kept you waiting I didn’t hear the door. Had the darn TV up loud.” Gacy explained as he invited Matt in.
“I could tell.” Matt laughed “I heard some screaming.” What were you watching
“A slasher movie. Boy, do they make the screams louder than the rest of the movie.” Gacy joked “What can I help you with?”
Matt sat down “I sent you a couple of messages and tried ringing but as I was nearby I thought I’d drop by. Ben, you know Ben my brother has been on my back about offering him a job at the gym.” Matt explained before adding “I told him that it wasn’t a good idea and that I didn’t approve. He got mad but on thinking about it more I think it could be good for us and wanted to see what you thought.”
From the other room Ben could hear his older brother’s voice, unfortunately for Ben the wash towel that Gacy had rammed in his mouth had moved and now blocked his airway Ben was frantically trying to dislodge it but the reality was unless someone did it for him he didn’t stand a chance. In one final attempt he got up to go to the door, he’d managed to make it a few steps before collapsing on the floor.
Gacy was just about to speak when Matt asked “what was that.?”
“That darn cat.” Gacy replied “He loves knocking things over. But back to the subject at hand. I think bringing Ben on board would be a good idea.”
A smile formed on Matt’s face, “Awesome. Well when he comes home and stops throwing a tantrum I’ll let him know we discussed it.”
“Let me know what he says.” Gacy replied as Matt got up to leave to head to the gym.
“I got a big workout I don’t want to be late for.” Matt said “Catch you later big man.”
Gacy showed Matt out and then went to continue his fun with Ben.
“Looks like you didn’t need to come around.” Gacy said as he opened the door before adding “Oh shit” as he found himself staring at Ben’s lifeless body on the floor. Gacy rolled Ben onto his back as the young man’s stared up at him. He checked for a pulse and could not find one but did see the washcloth protruding from the back of Ben’s throat.
“You fucker.” Gacy exclaimed as he hit Ben on his chest “I wanted more fun with you but waste not want not.”
He undid the handcuffs and pulled Ben’s track bottoms down before letting his hands explore the young man’s body.
He then fucked Ben’s body and decided what he wanted to do.
Ben’s disappearance was going to draw attention soon and Gacy knew he had to dispose of the young man’s body. He dug Ben’s grave and planted the young man next to Shannon.
Ben had died too quickly which meant Gacy needed to enjoy himself with his next victim.